Supervisors who cannot tear themselves away from their smartphones while meeting with employees risk losing their employees' trust and, ultimately, their engagement, according to new research from Baylor University's Hankamer School of Business.
The study, published in the journal Computers in Human Behavior, was conducted by James A. Roberts, Ph.D., professor of marketing, and Meredith David, Ph.D., assistant professor of marketing.
Their research examines "boss phubbing" (boss phone snubbing), which the researchers define as "an employee's perception that his or her supervisor is distracted by his or her smartphone when they are talking or in close proximity to each other" and how that activity affects the supervisor-employee relationship.
"Our research reveals how a behavior as simple as using a cell phone in the workplace can ultimately undermine an employee's success," Roberts and David write.
"We present evidence that boss phubbing lowers employees' trust in their supervisors and ultimately leads to lower employee engagement."
The research comprised three studies that surveyed 200, 95, and 118 respondents, respectively.
Those 413 who were surveyed—representing both supervisors and employees—responded to statements that assessed the nature of their work, levels of trust, and engagement.
Examples of survey statements included: "My boss places his/her cellphone where I can see it when we are together;" "When my boss' cellphone rings or beeps, he/she pulls it out even if we are in the middle of a conversation;" and "I can rely on my supervisor to keep the promises he/she makes."
The study found:
- 76% of those surveyed showed a lack of trust in a supervisor who phubbed them.
- 75% showed decreases in psychological meaningfulness, psychological availability, and psychological safety.
- The lack of trust and decreases in those key areas led to a 5% decrease in employee engagement.
"Employees who experience boss phubbing and have lower levels of trust for their supervisor are less likely to feel that their work is valuable or conducive to their own professional growth, and employees who work under the supervision of an untrusted, phubbing supervisor tend to have lower confidence in their own ability to carry out their job," David says. "Both of those things negatively impact engagement."
Phubbing is a harmful behavior. It undermines any corporate culture based on respect for others.
"Phubbing is a harmful behavior," he argues. "It undermines any corporate culture based on respect for others. Thus, it is crucial that corporations create a culture embodied by care for one another."
David adds that employees and supervisors alike cannot be fully present in face-to-face interactions when distracted by their smartphones.
"Developing the self-control to put away your smartphone in favor of meaningful, distraction-free interactions with your supervisor and other coworkers will yield benefits that far outweigh that text message, unread email, or social media post," she says.
Tips for Managers
The study offers several steps that managers can take to change the culture and mitigate the negative effects of smartphone use in the workplace:
- Create a culture in which supervisors do not feel pressure to immediately respond to emails and messages from their superiors while meeting with their employees.
- Structure performance criteria in a manner that motivates bosses to build healthy superior-subordinate relationships. This might include annual ratings by their subordinates.
- Train supervisors and employees on the importance of face-to-face interactions and sensitize them to the potentially negative consequences of phubbing on employee attitudes and engagement.
- Set formal smartphone policies by setting clear rules for smartphone use, access, and security—and detail specific consequences for violating those rules.
"Given that smartphone use in the workplace is nearly universal and has become an integral mode of communication, it is crucial that researchers investigate the impact of smartphone use in the workplace on career choices and adjustment," Roberts and David write.
"Today's employees face the real possibility that, left unattended to, smartphone use may complicate their careers by undermining vocational adjustment and lowering their job engagement."
This article is based on materials provided by Baylor University and has been edited for style and length.