AI Note-Takers in the Workplace: Legal Risks for Employers

The following article first appeared in the News & Insights section of Carmody Torrance Sandak Hennessey’s website. It is reposted here with permission.
Key Takeaways for Employers
- Use approved AI tools: Consider permitting only pre-approved, enterprise-level AI note-takers and prohibiting open-source tools.
- Establish clear policies: Implement written policies governing when AI note-takers may be used, which meetings may be recorded, and who may access transcripts and summaries.
- Restrict during sensitive meetings: Generally prohibit AI note-takers during meetings involving personnel decisions, confidential business information, or privileged legal matters.
- Obtain participant consent: Ensure all meeting participants are informed of and consent to AI recording and transcription.
- Consider litigation risks: Remember that AI-generated transcripts and summaries of non-privileged meetings may be discoverable in litigation.
Artificial intelligence note-taking tools are becoming increasingly common in the workplace. These tools can improve efficiency by recording, transcribing, and summarizing meetings.
However, a recent employment discrimination case filed in New Jersey illustrates just one risk that these tools can create for employers, particularly when used during personnel discussions.
Waninger v. Marathon Engineering
In August 2026, Lindsay Waninger, a former environmental scientist employed by Marathon Engineering & Environmental Services, Inc., filed a lawsuit alleging gender discrimination under the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination.
Waninger alleges in her complaint that she had worked for Marathon for approximately three months. She claims that she satisfactorily performed her job duties and there was never any indication of performance issues.
Nevertheless, Marathon terminated her employment during a video conference meeting that was attended by several management employees.
The termination meeting was recorded and notes were taken by an AI-powered tool.
Waninger states in her complaint that the termination meeting was recorded and notes were taken by an AI-powered tool known as Fireflies.ai.
Waninger claims that she was told during the meeting that things were not “working out.”
After Waninger left the termination meeting, several management representatives remained on the call and continued to discuss the termination.
Transcript Distribution
They also talked about what characteristics they wanted in a replacement employee and, according to the complaint, one manager described the ideal replacement as “[h]opefully a relatively strapping young man.”
The AI tool continued recording after Waninger left the termination meeting and subsequently distributed an email with a link to a transcript of the entire meeting to the participants, including Waninger.
The transcript apparently captured the post-termination discussion, including the alleged comment about wanting a young male replacement.
The transcript apparently captured the post-termination discussion.
Waninger claims that the post-termination comments demonstrate that her gender was a determinative and/or motivating factor in the termination decision.
She is seeking equitable relief, including reinstatement, and damages, including back pay, front pay, compensatory damages, costs, attorneys’ fees, and punitive damages.
The lawsuit is still pending and there has not been any finding on the merits.
What Should Employers Do
This case provides an important reminder that employers should carefully consider whether AI should be used to record and transcribe meetings.
Employers should strongly consider only allowing the use of pre-approved enterprise level AI-notetakers and prohibit the use of any open-source AI notetakers.
Employers should also have a written policy addressing when employees may use AI note-taking tools, the types of meetings that may be recorded, and who may access resulting transcripts and summaries.
Employers should generally prohibit AI note-takers from being used for sensitive meetings.
Employers should generally prohibit AI note-takers from being used for sensitive meetings such as meetings involving personnel decisions and meetings involving confidential business or legal matters.
Employers also should ensure that all participants in a video conference are aware and consent to the AI notetaker recording the call.
And, lastly, employers should keep in mind that AI transcripts and summaries of non-privileged meetings are discoverable in litigation.
About the authors: Vincent Farisello is a Carmody partner and co-chairs the Corporate & Business Group and Labor & Employment Group. Nick Zaino is a partner at Carmody and co-leader of the Corporate & Business Group.
RELATED
EXPLORE BY CATEGORY
Stay Connected with CBIA News Digests
The latest news and information delivered directly to your inbox.



